Barracude Problems… Seagate to be exact


I am running two servers, a few NAS devices, and a few computer. Each running at 3 hard drives up to 18 hard drives. Between all these machine I have installed a lot of hard drives, and some are running 24/7 months on end and only a restart to refresh the machines but other then that they rarely receive a break from their duties.

My ranking for drives from experience are in this order:

  • Western Digital
  • Maxtor (Bought out by Seagate)
  • Seagate

I have been reluctant to upgrade some of the drives to 1.5TB from Seagate due to technical issues that have been faced by these drives. They have even been bricked from recent firmware upgrades, I tried one 1.5TB drive and it kept locking up in the Windows Home Server, I unloaded it and tried it on another machine and I still faced problems with it, I returned to Hawalli for a refund and took the WD 1TB Green Drive, which works perfectly. I have had a few failures on the machines and the majority have been the Seagate Barracuda 7200.11 drives, luckily I keep the receipts and take them back to the Hawalli store and ask for an exchange for another brand. So after the last couple of years I am sticking to Western Digital drives when ever possible. Its not that drives don’t fail, they will eventually fail but the rate at which they fail is important. It seems Seagate’s track record isn’t looking too good for sometime now.

A guy who is just trying to enjoy life!


  1. tartooob

    Good thing to know, will stick with WD :)

  2. Maaz

    WD’s r the best and a suggestion dont update firmwares or drivers if evrything works fine.but ya i prefer WD .and try the new 7200.12 seagates they r much faster and no probs as far as i am concerned..

    (ps.need any tech help ,stay in touch).

  3. I was planning on upgrading my nas drives, looks like I’ll get WDs now.

  4. psytrance

    when it comes to hard disks ,you can never say when it will crash factors like voltage fluctuation,heat,constant read /write or even physical force are your main enemies.

    i prefer maxtor more than seagate and western digital.

Comments are closed.